Phoenix’s autograph squeeze: Booming memorabilia market tests the rail at Chase Field

The scramble for autographs at Chase Field is colliding with a booming memorabilia market, forcing Arizona Diamondbacks players to make split-second judgments about who gets a signature and who walks away empty-handed. That tension played out in fresh reporting this week from Cronkite News on the rise of autograph hounds alongside everyday fans.

The consequence is not just bruised feelings. It is a fan-experience problem the team and league will have to manage, and a privacy and safety issue when the chase follows players into hotels, coffee lines or family time. The pressure is amplified by the industry’s growth in Phoenix, where Pristine Auction president Jared Kavlie told Cronkite News the company expects to exceed $150 million in 2026 sales after operating under $100 million before 2020.

On the field, some players keep it simple. “I’m usually pretty open to sign as long as I’m not warming up to pitch in a game,” Diamondbacks pitcher Ryne Nelson said to Cronkite News. “I try to take care of the kids first.” Nelson added he does not want to turn people away for fear of missing those “who want them for the right reasons.”

Others draw firmer lines. Diamondbacks closer Paul Sewald told Cronkite News that “the people who ask at the team hotel aren’t going to get my autograph,” adding that family and coffee runs are off-limits. At the ballpark, though, he views signing as part of the job. “We spend a lot of time at the field, so if you want an autograph, get one there.” He said he can spot resellers with backpacks of items but does not police intent, signing one or two and moving on.

The etiquette is hardly new. Reporter Michael Russo has described Hall of Famer Pavel Bure’s tactic of insisting on personalizing autographs to deter resales. Cronkite News also recounted recent incidents away from venues that crossed the line, from a fan who filmed NFL star Ja’Marr Chase on a flight after a refusal to an autograph seeker who tailed Stephen Curry’s car for nearly 30 miles in 2015.

The market keeps feeding the frenzy. Kavlie, whose Phoenix company now operates more than 60,000 square feet and ships over 1,000 packages a day, told Cronkite News the industry increasingly runs on comparable sales, “a lot like the stock market.” Longtime collector Mike Moynihan put it more bluntly: if someone can charge triple digits for a signature, it is because buyers are paying it.

That price signal has consequences at the rail. When adults arrive with stacks of photos, kids can get crowded out. Fans may not see a difference from a distance, but players do. Blue Jays pitcher Trey Yesavage told a hobby podcast, as reported by Cronkite News, that he does not return mail requests. The line between public appearance and private life is something players are now setting for themselves.

Veterans say the human connection still matters. Hall of Famer Fergie Jenkins told Cronkite News he will sign one item and move on, a nod to today’s resale reality, and he echoes Harmon Killebrew’s advice to write clearly so fans can treasure it. Former MVP Dale Murphy said he still enjoys personal interactions even as he signs thousands through corporate deals.

For teams and cities, the policy question is practical, not theatrical. Markets will do what markets do, and heavy-handed crackdowns risk punishing families more than flippers. Clearer boundaries about time and place, kids-first windows at the park, and consistent off-site no-hounding expectations would protect access where it belongs and reduce confrontations where it does not.

In the meantime, Phoenix’s memorabilia boom is not slowing, according to Cronkite News’ interviews. That means the autograph ritual is going to keep testing patience and priorities. Right time, right place, and for the kids first may be the only workable rule until the industry finds a sustainable balance.

See an error? Email corrections@saguarosignal.com. We append material corrections to the article.